Friday, September 14, 2012

Why is John Allen a respected Catholic journalist?

John Allen
 Perhaps it's time for a new eyeglass prescription?

Surely not for mush-mouthed lead sentences like this one:

"Even before the deaths of U.S. Ambassador Christopher Stevens and three other Americans in Libya on Tuesday, Pope Benedict XVI’s Sept. 14-16 trip to Lebanon shaped up as a high wire act."

The "deaths"?  Makes it sounds like they succumbed to the flu, whereas the Ambassador and other Americans were outrageously murdered in a premeditated manner, and the Ambassador's body was publicly defiled afterwards.   All the world knows this; why would Allen attempt to obscure facts, much less notorious ones?  Willful blindness like that displayed by John Allen never leads to wisdom or peace.

Thursday, September 13, 2012

I thought Inigo Hicks was

Cardinal Ravasi strikes his "most interesting man in the Church" pose


Alas, according to John Allen, the most interesting man in the Church is not Inigo Hicks but Italian Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi.   Ravasi is for dialogue with non-believers, which strikes me as a lot of pointless blah-blah, but opinion makers tend to find entertainment of this type endlessly fascinating.

Monday, September 10, 2012

For Jesuits, abuse scandal is giant real estate opportunity

Home to Philadelphia's Archbishops since 1935; soon to be Jesuit owned


In 2007, when the Archdiocese of Boston was looking to raise cash to pay off its clerical abuse liabilities, the Jesuits of Boston College helpfully offered to buy the archbishop of Boston's residence and 65 surrounding acres for $400 million.  Recently, as the Archdiocese of Philadelphia looks to raise cash for the same purpose, the Jesuits of St. Joseph's University have offered $10 million for its archbishop's residence and 9 surrounding acres.   Another thing to note is that the price of an archbishop's residence is dropping like a rock.

Friday, September 7, 2012

Quietly Heroic Chinese Cardinal Dies

Cardinal Shan


Though the world is mostly indifferent, the Catholic Church in China suffers a great deal at the hands of the brutal Communist regime which rules that country.  One of the Church's leaders, Cardinal Paul Shan Kuo-Hsi, recently died, but because Cardinal Shan did not entertain trendy views regarding morality or dogma, his death, unlike that of his fellow Jesuit Cardinal Martini of Milan, was not considered newsworthy.   Nor did Cardinal Shan receive any fawning elegies from media bigwigs the way Cardinal Martini did.  However, one senses that winning adulation from the news media  was not among Cardinal Shan's goals.   Chiesa has more here.

Thursday, September 6, 2012

The Liturgical Movement

Fr. Romano Guardini


The Liturgical Movement was a scholarly movement begun in the nineteenth century which intended to reform Catholic liturgy by returning to medieval modes of worship.  Medieval worship was considered by members of the Liturgical Movement to be liturgy's ideal form.  Somehow, in the course of the twentieth century, this movement became diverted to a very different purpose.  Remarkably, the Liturgical Movement, which began in admiration of medieval worship, eventually helped produce the Novus Ordo, which no more resembles medieval worship than the Port Authority Bus Terminal resembles Chartres Cathedral. 

Fr. Romano Guardini (1885 AD - 1968 AD), a German notwithstanding his name, was a leading figure in the Liturgical Movement during its wholesome phase.  The following is taken from his text "The Spirit of the Liturgy," published in 1918:

The liturgy as a whole is not favorable to exuberance of feeling.  Emotion glows in its depths, but it smolders merely, like the fiery heart of the volcano, whose summit stands out clear and serene against the quiet sky.  The liturgy is emotion, but it is emotion under the strictest control.  We are made particularly aware of this at Holy Mass, and it applies equally to the prayers of the Ordinary and of the Canon, and to those of the Canon, and to those of the Proper of the Time.   Among them are to be found masterpieces of spiritual restraint.

....And how necessary this discipline is!  At certain moments and on certain occasions it is permissible for emotion to have a vent.  But a prayer which is intended for the everyday use of a large body of people must be restrained.







Wednesday, September 5, 2012

The Church was also a mess before Vatican II

Unfairly blamed ?


Though it's in a much worse mess now.   So says Francis Phillips.  Comments are worth a look, too.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

"Greatest Generation" not done yet

They've still got guts, and firepower is more than adequate

92 year old WW II vet shoots intruder in heart.